Reasons to fight

Facebooktwittergoogle_pluspinterestmail

mmom-working-with-baby-on-lapbecause-I-said-so-greenI’ve always felt like the so-called “Mommy Wars” were a bit blown out of proportion. Do you feed your kid organic baby food that you grew with your own co-op? That’s awesome! I so admire you. Do you use McDonald’s chicken nuggets as bribery when your daughter’s melting down at Walmart? I love it! We’d probably be friends.

Either way, what’s the big deal? There’s no need to call out the troops. No one wants to fight about your parenting choices.

Or so I thought.

Then I wrote a silly, diary-style article about what my day looks like as a stay-at-home mom. It was satire, sure, although the baby getting covered in insect glue and the daughter dumping all of the clothes from her drawers really happened.

I meant it as a quick, lighthearted read, not commentary on women’s roles in society. So I was shocked by the intensity of some of the comments left by readers at the end of the article.

One reader said I made stay-at-home moms look “like stupid teenage babysitters who can’t manage a household.”

Another poster, who gets up at 4:30 a.m. to clean and exercise, said:

  • If you think being a stay-at-home mom is hard, try being a working mother who does all the same stuff as a SAHM plus works 8 hours a day.”

And then there was the reader who felt I wasn’t giving enough credit to working dads, because the article teased my husband about the golf and restaurant lunches that are part of his work week:

  •  “It’s sad that this article doesn’t take anything into consideration that might possibly indicate the level of sacrifice “dear husband” makes.”

Many of the other remarks were positive. And as a writer, I’m over the moon that people even took the time to read and comment.

Untitled-1But it made me wonder if the battle continues, almost 20 years after Leslie Morgan Steiner published the book “Mommy Wars: Stay-at-Home and Career Moms Face Off on Their Choices, Their Lives, Their Families.”

Have we just moved the fighting to the Internet and social media and expanded the scope to include things like homeschooling, immunizations, co-sleeping and breastfeeding? Clearly, there’s still a lot of tension bubbling just below the surface, especially anytime someone uses the words “stay-at-home mom.”  (Or homeschooling. Or immunizations. Or breastfeeding. Take a look at the chat boards on any mommy blog or parenting website.)

What is it about our choices that make us so defensive?

I’ve worked from home for the past eight years, since the birth of my first child, straddling the worlds of a stay-at-home mom and a career one. For me, it’s meant a bit of needed additional income. It’s also meant having a child banging on my office door while I’m trying to interview someone by phone. It’s not the perfect situation, but it’s what works for my family right now. And, even still, I feel guilty about it.

I feel guilty because I’m letting my daughter watch TV while I write this article. And I also feel guilty that this article won’t be perfect because eventually I’ll give up on it so I can play with her.  Guilt is just a part of motherhood, I think, an unproductive and toxic part when it goes unchecked. One of my friends who is a vice president for a major travel website once told me she feels guilty that she doesn’t feel guilty about working. It’s the sort of logic that makes your head spin, but I get it.

The thing I have learned in trying to balance work and family is that feminism of decades past sold us all a ridiculous lie. You can’t have it all. Man or woman, married or single, working in the home or at the office, we all have to juggle and compromise just to make it through the day. What would be nice is if we could help each other with that juggling, instead of attacking each other for the choices we’ve made. There’s no one right way to parent.

What matters is that you’re trying, that you love your kids, that you’re working to give them a good life, wherever that work may take place. You can’t have it all, true. But what you can have as a parent is, quite simply, fantastic. So why in the world are we fighting about it?

 

 

Share

Elyssa Andrus has worked as a journalist for 14 years, most recently as the lifestyle editor at the Daily Herald newspaper in Provo. She is a contributor to the KSL-TV show "Studio 5" and is co-author of the book "Happy Homemaking" (Cedar Fort, 2012) with Natalie Hollingshead. She lives with her husband and four young children in Utah Valley.

4 Comments

  1. Sara Light Reply

    Well written! I’ve been a 100% stay at home mom, a work at home stay at home mom, and a working a full time job out of the home mom (while going back to school!). Any way you cut it, we’re all moms who love our kids and are always doing our best in the situation we’re in.

    Either I’m just lucky in the friends I have, or I somehow avoid the bashers, but I’ve never had to deal with snotty comments. The few times I’ve heard someone start in on anything, it just seems painfully obvious that they are extremely insecure or unhappy about themselves, and they feel the need to put others down in a misguided attempt to raise themselves up. Meh. I just mentally shrug and move on to friends who don’t do that.

  2. Ellen Bahr Reply

    You hit the nail right on the head! I loved it. I’ve often wondered why women in particular get so defensive about their parenting and career choices. Those who choose to criticize your brilliantly funny article about a day in your life need to find their senses of humor. Haven’t we all had days like that? I, for one, have had PLENTY. We may as well laugh about it and enjoy the ride!

  3. Debra Wing Reply

    AGREED! To breastfeed or not to breastfeed? To work or stay home? To each their own. I agree that there is no easy choice. Different things work for different families. I work one day a week and I wish I could work more. I love my kids and I love staying home too. Can’t we all just get a long??

  4. Steve Reply

    On top of writing engaging articles, raising fun and well balanced kids, taking readers moronic feedback with a smile, you still find the time to occasionally feed me, your non cooking bachelor brother-in-law! In your search for balance I am pretty sure I know which of those will be eliminated first! .)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *